Structure
of the Examination
This examination should take one hour. You will
be expected to write about eight bluebook pages. All the questions on the
examination will be taken from a list published about a week before the
examination. In order to reduce the anxiety associated with decision-making,
the questions to be answered will be selected by the instructor.
1. Definitions (1/2 to 1
page)—Definitions should state a genus & a specific difference. Clarifications
of other terms should use that structure when appropriate. They should, when
possible, also include an illustration. Points of contrast may also be helpful
in defining a term, as might a discussion of the importance of the term to
moral philosophy. A one line answer will generally be insufficient.
2. Distinctions (1-2 pages)—Define both
terms in a way that shows there
similarities and difference, as above. Then, if appropriate, say why the
distinction is important.
3. Arguments (1-2 pages)—State the
argument in a way that makes the conclusion and the premises on which it is
based clear. Then say informally why the author thinks the premises are true.
(This might include definitions of key terms or cases from which the premises
are induced.)
4. Statement of Theories (1-2 pages)—Say
what problem the theory is trying to resolve (or what question it is trying to
answer). Add definitions, examples, contrasts, &c., as necessary to clarify
the theory.
5. Essays (4 pages)—Essays should combine
definitions, distinctions, & arguments into a coherent & well-organized
exposition, comparison, & contrast of the subject matter.